Nestlé desperate
to link with Mandela says Lord Attenborough
Baby Milk Action Comment
on BBC Documentary:
Mandela : the Living Legend (BBC
One - 9pm 5th March 2003)
Updated: 12th March
2003
Health campaigners
have reacted with outrage and incredulity at scenes of Lord Richard
Attenborough attempting to persuade Nelson Mandela to take half
a million pounds for his Foundation from Nestlé in return
for a photo opportunity. South African media reported that Mandela's
Children Fund charity would not only refuse money from Nestlé,
but had done so in the past. A
report on iAfrica.com states:
"In a statement
it [Mandela's Children's Fund] reiterated the position it took
in 2000 regarding a donation Nestle proposed to the Fund. In
July 2000 the Fund was approached by Nestle, to contribute towards
its Aids Orphan Appeal, a theme it had adopted for Mandela's
birthday celebration with the children in that year.
"However
given the Nestle debacle in relation to HIV/Aids infected mothers
and their campaign on promoting formula milk as opposed to breast
milk and the disadvantages they put out publicly regarding breast
feeding, the Nelson Mandela Children's Fund declined the donation.""
In the BBC programme
Lord Attenborough was seen telling Mandela:
I know
that if you said, I want more money, knowing Nestlé
as I do, if (someone like you) said I wanted another half million
or another whatever it is for his own trust, you would have
it like that. They (Nestlé) are so desperate to reinstitute
themselves in South Africa, to be seen to have changed their
philosophies and that they are now totally in favour of everything
he (Mandela) stands for. May I ask him to ring you?
Mandelas Personal
Assistant, Zelda La Grange, then met with Lord Attenborough before
explaining to the interviewer:
Obviously
to be associated with Mandela means a lot but people
come from other angles wanting him to engage in different things.
Some of them may be laudable projects but people over
expose him they use him - they abuse him. Ive learned
to be extremely suspicious about people in this job, but you
have to be that way.
Nestlé is responsible
for more violations of international standards for the marketing
of baby foods than any other company. This malpractice contributes
to the unnecessary death and suffering of 1.5 million infants
around the world every year. Nestlés irresponsible
activities in two African countries were highlighted as recently
as January in the British Medical
Journal.
Baby Milk Action is
not aware of any official link between Nestlé and Lord
Attenborough, but he was seen in the programme pressing Mandela
to accept a personal call from a representative he knew at Nestlé.
Patti Rundal OBE, Policy
Director at Baby Milk Action, said:
"Knowing
Lord Attenborough's good works, it was a shock to see him appearing
to act as a messenger for Nestlé in the documentary.
We are increasingly worried by the reports we receive from our
partners in southern Africa about Nestlé's aggressive
and irresponsible promotion of baby foods. Nestlé is
desperate to improve its image by linking its name to good causes,
hoping nobody will check what they are really doing. The case
againt Nestlé is well documented. We need to see changes
on the ground, not slick public relations."
After a preview in
The Times by Andrew Pierce (20 February 2003) and a letter from
Baby Milk Action, Lord Attenborough apparently realised he was
stepping into controversy and his office put out a statement which
indicated that he attempted to have the programme changed. While
in the programme Lord Attenborough appeared to suggest he believed
Nestlé had changed its philosophies his statement
put forward a contrary view:
Lord Attenborough
supports UNICEFs position on the marketing of breastmilk
substitutes. The WHO International Code of Marketing of Breastmilk
Substitutes aims to support a childs right to the highest
level of health by ensuring that mothers are able to make informed
decisions about how to feed their babies, free from commercial
pressure. There is, however, evidence of routine violation of
the Code by all major companies, including Nestlé. UNICEF
expects all manufacturers of breastmilk substitutes, feeding
bottles and teats to comply with the Code in all countries.
UNICEF is reportedly
wanting to meet with Lord Attenborough to discuss his comments
and his role as a UNICEF Ambassador (The
Guardian 7th March 2003).
A spokesperson from
the Nelson Mandela Childrens Fund has told Baby Milk Action
that it would not accept money from Nestlé, because they
are aware of the problems with Nestlé's baby food marketing
activities. It has refused a donation in the past. We are still
awaiting a response from the Mandela Foundation on its funding
policy.
For further information
Patti Rundall, Policy
Director, Baby Milk Action, 23 St Andrew's St, Cambridge, CB2
3AX
Work Tel: 01223 464420, Mobile: 07786 523493, Fax: 01223 464417
email: prundall@babymilkaction.org,
or Mike Brady, Campaigns and Networking Coordinator.
Mobile: 07986 736179
email: mikebrady@babymilkaction.org
|